randy holmes-farley
Advanced Reefer
- Location
- Arlington, MA
Has anyone seen this study?
In addition to the fact that many current salt mixes are not represented:
1. Many of the results in that study do not reflect current salt mixes because they have intentionally changed them (I know this is true for some species in some salt mixes, for example).
2. I do not believe that some of the values represent current formulations based on my studies and those of other folks (copper and aluminum, for example). Perhaps they were correct when tested, but may no longer reflect current batches.
3. I am suspicious of some of the other values because they are approximately the same for every salt mix (suggestive of artifact, IMO). These might all be correct, especially if they all use the same bulk suppliers, but it is surprising to me, and sends up a yellow flag to check on them.
In addition to the fact that many current salt mixes are not represented:
1. Many of the results in that study do not reflect current salt mixes because they have intentionally changed them (I know this is true for some species in some salt mixes, for example).
2. I do not believe that some of the values represent current formulations based on my studies and those of other folks (copper and aluminum, for example). Perhaps they were correct when tested, but may no longer reflect current batches.
3. I am suspicious of some of the other values because they are approximately the same for every salt mix (suggestive of artifact, IMO). These might all be correct, especially if they all use the same bulk suppliers, but it is surprising to me, and sends up a yellow flag to check on them.