NYPDFrogman said:
Hi NYPDFrogman - Frank ;-)
Congratulations for this very nice upgrade.
On the photographs above we can see among others a Regal Angel - Pygoplithes diacanthus and a Apolemichthys xanthopunctatus - Gold Flake Angel, both are sponge eaters and I have a Regal Angel and I feed her natural live sponge every now and then that I collect over here in our Rocky beaches.
Here and
here you can see a small video of her eating the live sponge. I know that in the Piers of New York Paul B collects/collected a sponge?!? of which I put bellow one photograph that He kindly gave me permission to post in reefforum.net some two years ago.
Photograph Kindly ceded by Paul Baldassano - New Hyde Park - New York
Yesterday I asked KathyC for Her most kind help on obtaining images of the sponge you can see in this
blog, which looks similar to the sponge that you see my Regal Angel eating in the video, however if it is the
red beard sponge -
Clathria prolifera - Red Beard Sponge - red variety specimen (very beautiful), then it might not be accepted, at least by Zanclus, as I could learn from Paul B which also kindly gave me permission to post an image of if.
Photograph kindly ceded by Paul Baldassano - New Hyde Park - New York
Some time ago I searched for the existence of
Hymeniacidon heliophila -
sun sponge which is very similar to
Hymeniacidon sanguinea and wrote it
here.
According to the information I got from Paul B, the read beard sponge grows many times on top the
orange sponge that Paul B gives or gave to the Zanclus, so there is a strong chance that this could be a source of natural food for sponge eating fishes such as the Regal Angel etc..., like the sponge I collect every now and then over here in Portugal. Nowadays at least one of the LFS when receiving sponge eating fish, they place a bit of the local sponge in the exhibit tank, so that the fish gets access to a food source similar to is natural food source, and this helps to improve success.
Well I would like to know if you give or gave any time, live sponge to your sponge eating fish or if the idea occurred to you...
One last thing, sponges can be dangerous, so if tried, it must be in
very small quantity. I gained experience with
Hymeniacidon sanguinea and
Halichondria paniceia -
breadcrumb sponge that I
collect locally
Breadcrumb sponge and the evidence of it existing in Long Island
bellow you can see my fish sharing algae and natural sponge, meaning the ones looking for algae, eat the algae while Zanclus eats both.
http://www.reefforum.net/photopost/s...o/7412/cat/534
http://www.reefforum.net/photopost/s...o/7413/cat/534
http://www.reefforum.net/photopost/s...o/7414/cat/534
Well this said/written there might be a possibility for us to improve the diet of our sponge eating fish which can both be of help as they will be healthier, happier and also not look for what they don't really eat but can if there is nothing else, which some times is confused with reef safe issues and might not have a thing to do with it. Also by providing a natural food source, we are meeting nature demands and higher success possibilities as well as gaining further knowledge which can make the difference. One more thing, Paul B never ceases to be an inspiration ;-)
Once more, congratulations for your nice upgrading.
Cheers
Pedro Nuno ;-)