Eli isn't the best QB in the league but he is decent. If we let him go after 2 years, who are we going to replace him with? There's nobody. Are you going to draft another QB and hopely let him become like Brady?
Eli is easily the top 10 QB this year in the league. We were in the playoff for last 3 years, and he just had his first playoff win. It's very slow process but he is improving. I doubt he will be like his brother but I think he will be good enough for Giants to become a champion. We are very close right now.
As i remember, Phil Simms had a couple of shaky seasons before we won. i think the jury is still out on Eli, think of it this way....would you rather be in the Jets shoes? and Rivers is not that much better in San Diego