I do ALOT of business with a shop in Glen Cove. its a bit far from you but if you want the job done 110% I would recommend Martino Auto Concepts. They have a multi floor facility with one dedicated to exotics, lambos, Ferrari, ext. I wouldn't recommend them if they treated each job as a lambo, but I have tons of personal experience with normal insurance repairs and collision with them.
look them up and speak to either Joe, John, or Derek and say James with the orange GTR sent you. Youll get treated right.