• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

Dewman

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is killing me.
I put a lot of thought into my next fish purchase. I only have a 10 gallon nano, but I wanted a spectacular fish with a lot of color. I already have a yellow clown goby, so I wanted something that really contrasted against the rest of the tank.
I decided on Red Firefish(Nemateleotris magnifica). I know most reefers here will not be too impressed with this fish, as most of them are well past the "dartfish stage". I however, really think the Red Firefish is one of the most elegant and beautiful fish out there. This was to be the final fish purchase for my little ten gallon.

I brought my beautiful fish home, drip acclimated him/her over about 30 mins, and dropped it in the tank. It looked beautiful. Perfectly happy, and immediately started looking for something to eat. I happily obliged by adding some brineshrimp/selcon to the tank which was eagerly gobbled up. I was happy.

I turned my back on the tank for 25 mins to go cook dinner, and when I came back, I found the fish on the floor dried up.
My heart was broken, I put the fish on the table next to the tank and ate my dinner quickly. About half way through, I had to go to the kitchen to get some pepper, on the way, I decided to throw the fish back into the tank and let the Sally Lightfoot chew on the dead fish for a while.
When I was done with dinner, i came back to the tank to scoop out what was left of the dead fish, and I was shocked! The half eaten firefish was thrashing around in the claws of the crab, fully alive trying to get away.
I was horrified. I immediately got the turkey baster and shot some water at the crab to make it let go. It was too late though...the firefish was missing all its pectoral fins and one eye. it couldn't stay upright in the water alothough it was swimming everywhere.
I felt terrible, i grabbed the fish and quickly dispatched it with a kitchen knife. It's suffering was over. I cut it into small pieces and fed it to the flower anemones and the crabs.

I wonder if I had just cradled it in my hands in the water for a few minutes, if it would have come back to normal again??? I never have had a fish jump out before...
I thought I had thought of everything, i guess I didn't think about a cover though. My carelessness caused a death.
I will start lookoing for some way to cover the tank now...
 

Attachments

  • firefish.jpg
    firefish.jpg
    14.2 KB · Views: 2,276

Supergenius74

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have had a couple of freshwater fish in the past that got ick from other fish i had just bought. I seperated them into a hospital tank and kept them from just giving up, its kind of a natural instinct that when they are sick to just give up even though they are not dead yet, with some patience and help from food and chemicals a few have come back to live great lives. My saddest story is from an albino oscar I had who sas about 4" long when I added a jack dempsy, I was still learning at the time and the guy at the fish store told me it would be ok. Well they got along for about a week or so and one morning before work I noticed the jack dempsy chasing my oscar around the tank, the oscar bythe way was twice his size. Well I went on to work and just figured that they were being territorial and I let it go. When I got home I found my oscar floating on the top and all torn up like something had tried to eat him alive, I rushed him to my hospital tank and tried to keep him alive, he looked so sad, he literally had chunks biggen out of him and he was barley breathing I held him in the water and tried to keep some current over him but after about 10 min he stopped breathing and died in my hand. I was furrious, I wanted to to do the same thing to the jack dempsy but just gave him back to the store, told them I was not happy with the advice and that I would be going elseware. I was so upset I even burried the fish and said a prayer, I know sounds corny but I hate seeing animals suffer from my stupid mistake. Sorry about your loss, live and learn.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Sorry to hear of your loss Dew..

Rest assured, it's not totally in vain though.. - You sharing your story here has convinced me to be doubly cautious about their jumping habit when I decide to finally get mine.

I've been leaning stronger and stronger towards one for my 30g nano but holding off on making the decision because I want to make sure everything has the greatest chance of compatibility as possible. - I want to get a royal gramma for the 30 as well but I'm not sure if a firefish and a gramma are likely to get along..

If you decide to try again, I'd recommend some glass covers over the top. (I already have some for mine, but need to fill in the gaps at the back between the overflow/returns..)
 

MelanieF

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The gramma and firefish will get along fine if you add the firefish first and let him have free reign for a while. I have a firefish in my 20 gallon long now w/ a tank cover and he's absolutely my favorite fish. He has such a personality. Years ago I had a firefish, a royal gramma, and a longnose hawkfish in a 29 gallon w/ no issues at all. They all eat the same food but found a way to get along.
 

Expos Forever

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I agree the firefish is one of the nicest fish available. The decoras and helfrichis (sp?) are very nice also. Good luck jump-proofing your tank.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Good luck getting a Heifrich's! :P

That completely sucks. You must have felt sick watching that, but honestly, how could you have known? Well, now you know, just cuz they're not moving and look dried up doesn't mean that they're gone yet. However, I'd watch that Sally Lightfoot in such a small system.
 

Dewman

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Thanks everyone... I just feel so stupid. :roll:

I have read so many times about how they "dart" when they're spooked. I just wasn't thinking clearly.

Seamaiden... about the crab, yeah, I know what you mean. I have never seen one attack a fish, but when I used to stick my arm in the 75 to pick up things that fell into the tank, my HUGE Sally would run out and attack my hand. It ALWAYS scared me, without fail. I would always yank my arm out of my tank and scream like a girl. Maybe because they look so damn much like a big spider! And I hate spiders...
Imagine a 6'2" , 195 lb guy sreaming and dancing around when his crab scared him. :wink:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I lost a fire fish from it jumpin out too. Sucked the big one.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Dewman":1dn4krk6 said:
Thanks everyone... I just feel so stupid. :roll:

I have read so many times about how they "dart" when they're spooked. I just wasn't thinking clearly.

Seamaiden... about the crab, yeah, I know what you mean. I have never seen one attack a fish, but when I used to stick my arm in the 75 to pick up things that fell into the tank, my HUGE Sally would run out and attack my hand. It ALWAYS scared me, without fail. I would always yank my arm out of my tank and scream like a girl. Maybe because they look so damn much like a big spider! And I hate spiders...
Imagine a 6'2" , 195 lb guy sreaming and dancing around when his crab scared him. :wink:

Dammit, ya made me LAUGH OUT LOUD with that one.. :lol:
 

TomH

Active Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
seamaiden":7uaw65k0 said:
Good luck getting a Heifrich's! :P

I believe that Liveaquaria.com has them in stock, for anyone who's interested (and, of course, has the means to purchase -- $189!!.)

Tom
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hmm, I've seen them for much cheaper SM. 100 at a LFS, and a while back TMC was selling pairs for 195...they've recently raised the price A LOT though, I don't know why.
 

PeeJ

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
that is a sad story...especially when one is in an already sad mood. its funny how people get attatched to such animals. id be crushed if i lost any of my fish. even though they cant physically speak, they all have voices in my head. you know? like if they could talk....

i always picture my lion as a french guy.....
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Matt_Wandell":3ra10j9n said:
Hmm, I've seen them for much cheaper SM. 100 at a LFS, and a while back TMC was selling pairs for 195...they've recently raised the price A LOT though, I don't know why.

Demand.
 

Quigonsean

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Don't feel weird or dumd about burrying the fish. A year and half ago we had a major power outage, and lost my Clarks Clown name of Griswald, and my brother's Russel's Lionfish called Leo. We burried them, infact out in my backyard next to the shed is a cross made of wood with their names on it. We also lost an Albino Oscar called Stinky Pinky, and burried her too. We did this at as my idea not my little brother and I'm 30 years old he is 20 uears old. Maybe it sounds kinda kiddiyish, but to me they where pets. They were not just fiush to flush no big deal, no these where pets as all my fish are. My fish are as much a pet as both my dog and cat. When I lost my Baby Clown trigger to cyanide sickness I even cried a little, Skelton was his name and he was my favorite pet fish. Maybe I'm a wuss puss but since they are like my dog and cat losing them is like losing my dog or cat. I don't care how old you are if your dog or cat dies you'll bawl so with the fish being same as a pet dog or cat a few little tears is all good not a wussy babyish thing. Oh yeay my Clown Trigger Skelton he got a grave with cross as well. S I feel for you, and am sorry for your loss, any pet lost sucketh the wet donkey knob. It's not stupid to care. Please accept my condolences.

Sincerly,
Sean Ward
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
That is sooooo sad man. Sorry.

I love my firefish...Flicker the Firefish. Awesome looking fish.


I am so paranoid about him jumping that the top is completely sealed and if I don't see him right away I run around the tank to check the overflow...this happena a few times a day. :oops:


I had a blenny jump ship and found him still wet...only out for a few minutes, as I had just seen him in. I ploped him back in and did fishy CPR, which is swishing them around to pump water through their gills, but the fish was gone.


You did your best...better luck next time. :)
 

Trinity

New Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Such a shame about your firefish Dew, they really are beautiful. :cry:

I have kept fish for years and in an old 2ft freshwater tank I have community fish. I had cleaned it out one day and then later thought 'funny, the female swordtail isn't about'.

Looked and looked but she was nowhere. Then after a while I, for some unknown reason thought I'd look under the rug near the fishtank. There she was, underneath, in the middle!! (about 6ins from where my huge dog had just been lying!)

Now this fish must have been out of the water for at least an hour. No sign of life but I scooped her up and chucked her back in, just on the off-chance and low and behold, she does a little shimmy and swims off!!!

She lived for a good couple of years after that! I always stick fish back in these days... just incase!
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top