Matching a stain is near impossible. Should have stained a small peice first as a test. Also, was the wood you used "clear pine"? This wood accepts stain very well. Before staining, you should always sand, steel wool, clean with denatured alcohol, then condition the wood with BIX wood conditioner. This allows the clear pine to absorb the stain evenly. In some cases can change color.
Bringing that color back to Red is almost impossible. I hate to tell you that. Vigorus sanding with belt sander. Removing most of the brown. Then cleaning with denatured alocohol. Bix, then finding a Minwax DEEP Red stain, maybe mixed with an Ipswitch Pine 30% might achieve the original "Red Mohogany" color. Very light coats with a cheap sponge brush, or an old terry cloth rag.
Hope I helped.